In 2018, Medical News Today reported on a study warning that many people with type 2 diabetes may be over-monitoring their glucose levels, which may lead to the misuse of tests and supply waste.
Now, new research from the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN, warns that the United States faces a much more dangerous problem: the over-treatment of diabetes.
According to the study paper — which now appears in the journal Mayo Clinic Proceedings— many people receive too much glucose lowering therapy.
This increases a person’s risk of hypoglycemia, or abnormally low blood sugar levels.
“Hypoglycemia, or low blood glucose, is one of the most common serious adverse effects of diabetes therapy, causing both immediate and long term harm to [people] who experience it,” explains lead researcher Dr. Rozalina McCoy.
“Severe hypoglycemia, defined by the need for another person to help the patient treat and terminate their hypoglycemic event, is associated with increased risk of death, cardiovascular disease, cognitive impairment, falls and fractures, and poor quality of life,” she adds.
The researchers found that in the U.S., people with diabetes often receive much more medication than their hemoglobin A1C levels would require. Hemoglobin A1C levels are a person’s average blood sugar levels over a period of around 3 months.
In the cohort they studied, this resulted in 4,774 hospital admissions and 4,804 emergency department visits in the span of 2 years.
“Importantly, these numbers are a large underestimation of the true scope of over-treatment-induced hypoglycemic events,” warns Dr. McCoy.
Millions of people receive too much therapy
The researchers used 2011–2014 data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, as well as information from the OptumLabs Data Warehouse.
The team’s first step was to estimate how prevalent intensive glucose lowering therapy was in the U.S. by using National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey data.
They defined “intensive therapy” as taking one type of medication to achieve hemoglobin A1C levels of 5.6% or under, or taking two or several types of medication to achieve hemoglobin A1C levels of 5.7 to 6.4%.
Then, they used information from the OptumLabs Data Warehouse to estimate how many people with diabetes had visited an emergency department or the hospital because of hypoglycemia related to overly intensive treatment.
The team determined that 10.7 million non-pregnant adults with diabetes had hemoglobin A1C levels within recommended levels (under 7%). Of these, however, almost 22% received intensive glucose lowering therapy.
This means that as many as 2.3 million people with diabetes received overly intensive treatment between 2011 and 2014 in the U.S., the researchers found.
This was regardless of whether or not they had clinically complex profiles, such as:
- being aged 75 or over
- being limited in two or more daily activities, including eating or getting dressed, and walking from room to room
- having a diagnosis of end stage kidney disease
- having three or more chronic conditions
According to the study, 32.3% of the 10.7 million people in the cohort had clinically complex profiles. However, this did not seem to have any bearing on whether or not an individual received intensive treatment for diabetes.
“Older people and others we consider clinically complex are more at risk to develop hypoglycemia, as well as experience other adverse events because of intensive or over-treatment,” notes Dr. McCoy.
“However, at the same time, these [people] are unlikely to benefit from intensive therapy rather than moderate glycemic control,” she notes.
“When we develop a diabetes treatment plan, our goal should be to maximize benefit while reducing harm and burden of treatment.”
Dr. Rozalina McCoy
Over-treatment as harmful as under-treatment
The researchers explain that currently, most policymakers and healthcare professionals are committed to controlling hyperglycemia (high blood sugar levels) and reducing instances of under-treatment.
However, Dr. McCoy notes, there also needs to be more awareness of the dangers of over-treatment.
“We need to align treatment regimens and goals with each patient’s clinical situation, health status, psycho-social situation, and reality of everyday life to ensure that care is consistent with their goals, preferences, and values,” she advises.
“While some episodes of hypoglycemia may be unavoidable, especially if caused by un-modifiable risk factors such as need for insulin therapy, others may be preventable, as in the case of over-treatment,” explains Dr. Mc Coy.
She says that going forward, it is important that healthcare providers hit a balance in the recommendations they issue to their patients with diabetes.
“It is important not only to ensure that we do not under-treat our patients with diabetes, but also that we do not over-treat them because both under-treatment and over-treatment can harm our patients,” stresses Dr. McCoy.